2024: Brooklyn Voted Luke’s Lobster Best Lobster Roll!
Luke’s Lobster
11 Water St, Brooklyn
(917) 882-7516 – lukeslobster.com
Nestled beneath the iconic Brooklyn Bridge in the historic Smokestack building lies Luke’s Lobster, an epitome of seafood perfection. Renowned for crafting the finest lobster rolls in Brooklyn, Luke’s ethos revolves around simplicity and sustainability. Working directly with trusted fishermen, Luke’s ensures that every bite of their lobster, shrimp, or crab rolls is a testament to quality and ethical sourcing. Served in a toasted New England-style split-top bun, each roll is a harmonious blend of succulent seafood, a swipe of mayo, lemon butter, and Luke’s Secret Seasoning—a recipe perfected over three generations. From the modest 4oz to the indulgent jumbo rolls, every offering embodies the essence of Maine’s coastal cuisine. Whether you’re a local craving a taste of the sea or a visitor seeking authentic flavors, Luke’s Lobster beckons with its commitment to excellence and the freshest catch. Dive into a culinary journey where every roll is a celebration of the ocean’s bounty, right here in Brooklyn Bridge Park.
2023: Brooklyn Voted Red Hook Lobster Pound Best Lobster Roll!
Red Hook Lobster Pound
284 Van Brunt Street, Brooklyn
(718) 858-7650 – redhooklobster.com
The lobster roll is a staple of casual seafood cuisine, and the Red Hook Lobster Pound in Red Hook has perfected the art of creating a roll that’s equally succulent as it is fresh. Each roll is served on an authentic New England, top split, buttered and toasted bun with a side of your choice. Whether you’re craving a traditional lobster roll or something a bit more offbeat like a fried lobster roll or a BLT-styled roll, you’ll be satisfied with your choice. Red Hook Lobster Pound offers the freshest Maine lobster outside of Maine and is hard to resist on any given day. It’s not surprising why Brooklyn residents travel from all over for a chance to experience the best lobster rolls in the borough!
2022: Brooklyn Voted BK Lobster Best Lobster Roll!
BK Lobster
340 Bedford Ave
(347) 889-5485 – bklobster.com
There’s a reason why BK Lobster is referred to as “lobster roll central” – this seafood joint does not mess around when it comes to lobster rolls. The chefs at BK Lobster cook them to perfection and offer a variety of different flavors to choose from. Try it with the restaurant’s signature, original BK sauce, butter, or a jerk sauce. You can also choose to eat your lobster roll hot or chilled. Other popular options are the Lobster BTL Roll, served with crispy bacon, or the Bayridge Roll, served with roasted peppers and Italian dressing. Regardless of how you like your lobster roll, BK Lobster will not disappoint.
2021: Brooklyn Voted Red Hook Lobster Pound Best Lobster Rolls!
Red Hook Lobster Pound
284 Van Brunt St
(718) 858-7650 – redhooklobster.com
The lobster roll is a staple of casual seafood cuisine, and the Red Hook Lobster Pound in Red Hook has perfected the art of creating a roll that’s equally succulent as it is fresh. Each roll is served on an authentic New England, top split, buttered and toasted bun with a side of your choice. Whether you’re craving a traditional lobster roll or something a bit more offbeat like a fried lobster roll or a BLT-styled roll, you’ll be satisfied with your choice. Red Hook Lobster Pound offers the freshest Maine lobster outside of Maine and is hard to resist on any given day. It’s not surprising why Brooklyn residents travel from all over for a chance to experience the best lobster rolls in the borough!
2020: Brooklyn Voted Jordan’s Lobster Dock Best Lobster Rolls!
Jordan’s Lobster Dock
3165 Harkness Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 934-6300
Perhaps the best part about finding an amazing place to eat in New York City is the history that often comes along with the establishment. With more than 80 years of service, Jordan’s Lobster Dock is no different. What began as a lobster distribution and holding facilities where fresh seafood imported from Maine and Canada would be stored in wooden barrels in 1938, later evolved into a clam bar. The bay side eatery, which is family owned and operated, is a place where customers know they will get the finest and freshest seafood in the city, with a no-frills menu that highlights the ingredients.
2019: Brooklyn Voted Red Hook Lobster Pound Best Lobster Rolls!
Red Hook Lobster Pound
284 Van Brunt St.
(718) 858-7650 – www.redhooklobster.com
It’s a six-hour trip by car to Maine, the state that prides itself on delicious lobster rolls. Fortunately, Brooklynites don’t have to travel that far to get an amazing lobster roll right in their backyard. Red Hook Lobster Pound was the brainchild of Ralph Gorham and Susan Povich in 2008. While sitting at their dining table in Red Hook, Brooklyn devouring fresh lobsters that they had just brought back from a friend in Portland, Ralph proposed a crazy idea to his wife Susan. He suggested they open a lobster pound in an empty storefront in the building that they owned but were unable to develop due to the contracting credit markets. Red Hook was a natural location for a fish business; it was on the water and like the lobstering communities of Maine, it was inhabited by fiercely independent people. As it is cut off from most of Brooklyn by the BQE, it has developed a supportive community just like the Maine lobstering community.
2017: Brooklyn Voted Red Hook Lobster Pound Best Lobster Rolls!
Red Hook Lobster Pound
284 Van Brunt Street. (718) 858-7650. www.redhooklobster.com
Met with serious acclaim from all who try the fresh, seafood delights straight from the Maine coast offered up at Red Hook Lobster Pound; it’s no secret why the Brooklyn-based eatery with a food truck outpost is a foodie favorite. Their delectable lobster rolls are just one of the eatery’s outstanding menu items and is a definite must-try for anyone looking for some big deliciousness in the biggest borough.