With countless Brooklyn bakeries to choose from, who takes the coveted title of Brooklyn’s Best Cake? From classic vanilla to the most outrageous flavor combinations, our borough offers endless options. Brace yourselves, because the reader-voted winner is about to be revealed!
2024: Brooklyn Voted Simply Sweet Brooklyn Best Cake!
Simply Sweet Brooklyn
Bay Ridge, Brooklyn
(347) 853-0293 – simplysweetbrooklyn.com
Simply Sweet Brooklyn is the go-to destination for the best cakes in the borough, offering a delicious array of flavors and personalized options. Although the business operates entirely online, Simply Sweet Brooklyn excels in providing a seamless and delightful experience, from order to delivery. Their extensive menu includes an assortment of cake flavors, from classic vanilla and rich chocolate to more unique options like lemon and red (or pink or blue) velvet. Customers can customize their cakes with a choice of luscious fillings such as fruit preserves, chocolate ganache, or creamy custards, and finish them with various frostings, including velvety buttercream, silky cream cheese, or smooth ganache. Simply Sweet Brooklyn’s talented bakers take pride in their craftsmanship, creating beautifully decorated cakes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. With a focus on quality ingredients and meticulous attention to detail, Simply Sweet Brooklyn’s online service offers the ultimate convenience, making it a top choice for cake lovers seeking a sweet treat for any occasion.
2023: Brooklyn Voted Isabella’s Creations Best Cake!
Isabella’s Creations
6602 13th Avenue, Brooklyn
(347) 464-8445 – isabellascreations.com
Isabella’s Creations in Bensonhurst offers some of the most delectable cakes in all of Brooklyn. Their signature cake is a true work of art, made with only the finest ingredients and decorated with intricate designs that are almost too beautiful to eat. Customers rave about the rich, moist texture of the cake, which is perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness. Whether it’s for a birthday, wedding, or other special occasion, Isabella’s Creations can create a cake that will leave a lasting impression on all who taste it. Their attention to detail and commitment to quality make them a top choice for anyone in search of a truly unforgettable dessert experience.
2022: Brooklyn Voted Tasty Pastry Shoppe Best Cake!
Tasty Pastry Shoppe
8216 13th Ave
(718) 833-9493 – tastypastryshoppe.com
The name doesn’t lie! Those seeking the best cake in Kings County need look no further than Tasty Pastry Shoppe, a cute little Italian sweets shop dishing out every cake you could imagine. They’ve got everything: Johnnie Walker Blue AND Black Label cake, tie-dye top hat cake, and for the brave, a three-layer beast featuring Batman, Superman, and Spiderman cakes with a Hulk fist coming out the top.
2021: Brooklyn Voted Gather Best Cake!
Gather
341 7th Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 768-2439 – www.gatherny.com
Who doesn’t love to have their cake and eat it, too? Brooklynites with sweet teeth have made it clear, they love the cake at Gather. This cute and quaint eatery located in the heart of Park Slope doubles as a gourmet shop with a cafe vibe, dolling out sandwiches and prepared takeout fare, featuring just a few seats for dining in. And Brooklynites sure adore its baked goods (its chocolate cake, especially, is to die for). Wash it down with some of Brooklyn’s best coffee and you’ve got yourself a little cheat meal. If your mouth isn’t watering just yet, stop in for a slice and check it out for yourself!
2020: Brooklyn Voted Sugar Coated Bakery Best Cake!
Sugar Coated Bakery
1078 65th Street, Brooklyn
(718) 259-9884 – www.sugarcoatedny.com
“Sweet things made with love,” is the motto of this Brooklyn bakery, which features everything from custom baking to gingerbread house design classes. Sugar Coated Bakery is the place to get the cake you’ve been thinking about for that special day or event. Their goods are as sweet as their name. They can make whatever you’re looking for to liven up whatever you need. Talented bakers making custom cakes that are sure to impress and sure to be as delicious as they are beautiful to look at. They allow you to pick from a wealth of designs on their website and place your custom order. Soon, you’ll have a delicious cake that you’ll almost hate spoiling, it looks so good. But it tastes just as sweet.
2019: Brooklyn Voted Sugar Coated Bakery Best Cake!
Sugar Coated Bakery
1078 65th St.
(718) 259-9885 – www.sugarcoatedny.com
“Sweet things made with love,” is the motto of this Brooklyn bakery, which features everything from custom baking to gingerbread house design classes. Sugar Coated Bakery is the place to get the cake you’ve been thinking about for that special day or event. Their goods are as sweet as their name. They can make whatever you’re looking for to liven up whatever you need. Talented bakers making custom cakes that are sure to impress and sure to be as delicious as they are beautiful to look at. They allow you to pick from a wealth of designs on their website and place your custom order. Soon, you’ll have a delicious cake that you’ll almost hate spoiling, it looks so good. But it tastes just as sweet.
2017: Brooklyn Voted Villabate Alba Best Cake!
Villabate Alba
7001 18th Avenue (718) 331-8430 www.villabate.com
Italian cakes and pastries are baked with love, experience and professionalism at Villabate Alba. After years of hard work as simple, Sicilian breadmakers in bakeries all over Brooklyn, Angelo Alaimo and his son Emanuele finally reached their goal and opened a place of their own in 1979, Villabate of 18th Avenue– named after their hometown. At their bakery they brought only the finest in Italian creations, from cookies to cakes to pastries and of course, breads. As a family-owned and run business, the Alaimo family dedicate themselves to delivering only the most authentic Italian goods.